Sunday, 3 April 2011

Senator Jim Perchard Tell's us we are a shinning Light.

So Senator Jimmy Perchard tells us that Jersey is the best working Democracy in the World. So why do so many people think its Brocken then.




Have a Listen to his speech he made in the States last week when they were talking about.



States to sit 'in Committee' to discuss –

Review of the role of the Crown Officers ("Carswell Review"): ‘in Committee’ debate.

Presented: 14th March 2011.

Privileges and Procedures Committee.









Then have a Listen to Deputy Montfort Tadier of St Brelade No. 2. I’ve put it up in two parts because he did Rabbit a bit.

Part 1.



Part 2.



TheJerseyWay would like to Credit & Thank BBC Radio Jersey for making these recording's posible.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Perchard what is that guy on? Elections will soon be here and he'll soon be gone.

voiceforchildren said...

TJW.

Not only are you recording our "modern day" States Members, but as Montfort Tadier said, so is history.

Jersey a shinning beacon of Democracy? priceless Senator Perchard just bl--dy priceless! Wonder what the Historians will make of that little gem?

Anonymous said...

Well done putting up these speeches ahead of Hansard, which will take two weeks to be made available on the States website. What a pity the BBC do not put the States debates on line via the internet, as well as on the AM frequency. Perhaps PPC could look at that.

Both Perchard and Le Main gave vintage speeches. Backwoodsmen to the last!

It is quite apparent that Senator Perchard had not read the submissions to the Carswell enquiry and, even if he did, understood nothing. He was not alone however. The majority of States Members simply did not want to be debating this issue as they cannot understand the need for fundamental change. Only a few actually made submissions.

There is deep ignorance in the legislature and it behooves those that fail to vote to reflect on that abstention, to recognise that their disengagement results in the election of the uneducated and the prejudiced. The poor caliber of our States Members comes out time and again. It is to the detriment of government and any semblance of democracy. The power holders of the Crown Officers and Council of Minister have the system locked down solid and intend to keep it that way. Anything associated with the exercise of power is corrupted.

The current position of the Bailiff is untenable in a modern democracy. It is a feudal relic of a pre-democratic era. A torpedo with “separation of powers” written along its length, has already been launches and will strike amidships for certain. Those that cannot see the need for change are willfully blind.

Ian Evans said...

A shining beacon of democracy it undoubtedly is, but only for the rich and the pro establishment supporters.

"....the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must."

Thycydides

Anonymous said...

Mr. Perchard throw out a challenge to States members.

''I challenge any member in recent times to give an example of where the Bailiff when prociding over this assembly has displayed anything, but neutrality and impartiality''

Anonymous said...

@Anonymous 11.22pm

The members might have convenient amnesia, but elephants never forget.

Check this: http://visar.csustan.edu/aaba/Noaccountingfortaxhavens.pdf. The relevant portion is at the bottom of page 50 and the top of page 51.

Wallace said...

Anonymous said...
Well done putting up these speeches ahead of Hansard, which will take two weeks to be made available on the States website. What a pity the BBC do not put the States debates on line via the internet, as well as on the AM frequency. Perhaps PPC could look at that.


Channel Telly usually have a link to live internet-streamed States meetings, which can then be recorded using software like Audacity. However they sometimes fail to start the broadcast on time

Anonymous said...

Jimmy Perchard

Ian Evans said...

JERSEY'S MUGS